Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta disputes. Mostrar todas as mensagens
Mostrar mensagens com a etiqueta disputes. Mostrar todas as mensagens

sexta-feira, 9 de agosto de 2013

Back to School: Practice-Ready Legal Curriculum


Over 340 Years of 
Private Practice Experience 
Among ASL's Faculty




It frustrated me to no end when highly-ranked Washington and Lee University School of Law -- to much fanfare -- announced in 2008 their practice-ready curriculum for 3Ls students.  The press release from the school's Dean said:
[We] are embarking on a dramatic revision of [the] law school curriculum, entirely reinventing the third year to make it a year of professional development through simulated and actual practice experiences.  
This is one of the boldest reforms in American legal education since Dean Christopher Columbus Langdell pioneered the new curriculum at Harvard Law School in the late 19th century.
What?  WTF?  Appalachian School of Law had created -- from its inception in the mid-1990s -- a practice-ready, experiential curriculum for all students (not just 3Ls) long before Washington and Lee announced its program!  But for us, the pedagogical approach was so embedded in our institutional genes, we never thought to elevate it to a nationwide selling point.  Silly us!

What sets ASL apart from nearly all law schools is this.  Its faculty members, when taken together, have over 340 years of  private practice experience.  For example. I practiced for 20 years in the areas of energy, civil litigation, ADR, and insurance law before I joined the academy.  I still sharpen the saw by providing pro bono mediation services to parties appearing in area courts.  Ironically, one of my mentors, at the school where I earned my LL.M., advised me that all that private practice experience would taint me in academia.

It seems most law school faculties prefer faculty members who possess a purely theoretical bent, as opposed to a practical bent.  Luckily, I found an academic home where my colleagues welcomed the expertise I had garnered in the conference rooms, courts, and law offices where lawyers meet to argue, brief, negotiate, and solve legal problems.  For more about our faculty, see here.

I posted earlier about the nationally recognized externship program of the Appalachian School of Law.  Few law schools have anything like it in scale or coverage.  For more information, see here.



Also, our curriculum emphasizes the development of the following professional skills:
  • Legal writing and research throughout the curriculum, not just during the first year
  • Advocacy in trial and appellate courts
  • Advocacy in arbitration and mediation
  • Negotiation 
  • Client representation and counseling
  • Corporate and contractual transactions
  • Wills and trusts
  • Family law practice
  • Pre-trial practice
  • Insurance claims 
  • Mineral and natural resource management, and 
  • Small business counseling and drafting.
I do not intend that list to be exclusive.  I know it's not.  For more information about our course offerings, see here.

As noted in an earlier posting, we have award-winning moot court, mock trial, and ADR competition teams. Our practice-ready curriculum supports those successes.  

It also makes our students ready to face the demands of legal practice straight out of school.  Thank goodness for that because so many graduates and lawyers practice in small or solo practices where mentoring does not exist or may fall short of the needs of some new lawyers. Our graduates hit the ground running.

And, if I had to put money on a legal team, I'd choose ASL over W&L.  In fact, I have. Several years ago, we whooped W&L in a negotiation competition.  ;-)  

Yes, that is a very broad smile on my face. I love an under-estimated, underdog. Sic 'em, Fido.   ;-)

For more information, see here.

Dec. 31, 2014 Update:  This blog posting, criticizing a Harvard Law Course designed for students who want to become law professors, clearly identifies the difference between the so-called elite schools and the access schools.  At elite schools, professors produce scholarship.  At access schools, professors teach practice skills because we can.  We also produce scholarship, but it does not take priority over teaching and assessment.   We focus on student learning!


terça-feira, 25 de junho de 2013

Disputes Less Suitable for Mediation






Hal Abramson, the author of Mediation Representation: Advocating in a Problem-Solving Process, suggests that the following types of disputes or circumstances make mediation less desirable:

·        The party needs to establish binding precedent;

·        The party needs to deter future claims by establishing a “hard-ball litigation – no settlement reputation” (aka the Walmart strategy);

·        The party seeks validation or vindication by a person in authority who declares that the client was blameless, but the other party was a low-down, dirty SOB;

·        The party wants or needs to go for a litigated “jackpot” damage award, no matter the statistical chance of winning that award;

·        The parties are embroiled in a value-based conflict on which they see no room for compromise;

·        The party will not be effectively represented in mediation, either because he or she is unrepresented or represented by inexperienced or unskillful counsel;

·        One or more parties refuses to participate in good faith in the process; or

·        The parties cannot bring into the process one or more persons essential to a resolution.

I would add to this list disputes in which:

·        A party seeks retribution; or,

·        A weaker party needs the power of the court or of law to balance a significant imbalance of power or resources.

The Maryland Handbook for Lawyers identifies four types of disputes in which mediation would not be successful or is not considered appropriate:

·        When a party victimizes the other party;

·        When alcohol or drug abuse plays a significant role in the dispute or undermines a party’s ability to effectively participate in the mediation;

·        When only a court can offer a remedy to the dispute, especially in matters of first impression or those matters requiring injunctive relief; or,

·        When relationships cannot be healed. 

I would challenge two components of this last list.  

While the mediation community continues to debate whether victims of spousal abuse or domestic violence should ever participate in mediation, several authors suggest that with sufficient safeguards the process may offer an attractive alternative for abused spouses.  One of my former students, a victim of spousal abuse, wrote a seminar paper advocating the use of med-arb in divorce proceedings involving abused spouses.  After her experience in the West Virginia court system, in which a judge openly expressed his bias against her, she preferred a process giving her more control, especially, over the outcome.

I also suggest that mediators successfully handle many cases in which the parties either had no pre-existing relationship (auto accident cases) or do not wish to preserve the relationship (divorcing spouses with no children). 

As mediators, lawyers, and their clients gain more experience with mediation, fewer and fewer types of disputes will seem less amenable to the process.  Even if mediation only succeeds in improving the parties’ communication, in identifying their underlying interests, in narrowing the issues in conflict, or in helping them more carefully evaluate their litigation option, it can move the dispute towards a quicker, more cost effective resolution.  

This article first appeared in the St. Louis Lawyer, Dec. 2006, and was reprinted in The Insurance Receiver, Winter 2006 and at http://mediate.com/articles/young18.cfm (footnotes in original omitted in this posting).  By providing this information, the author does not intend to create an attorney client relationship with anyone reading or relying on this post.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...